Author Topic: Video Girl Ai vs. I"s Pure  (Read 80 times)

Offline nickjeromana

  • Rurou
  • *
  • Posts: 33
  • Karma: +0/-0
Video Girl Ai vs. I"s Pure
« on: December 31, 2011, 12:24:19 PM »
It was a very long manga series (both were actually)

Both were made into 6 Episode series.

Both were written as OVA series.

Both were arguably too short for their own good.

Both Mangas are so closely related that one may argue that they're one and the same.  Only one uses an Artificial Intelligence that pops out of a Video Cassette-Tape while the other is completely flesh and blood.

For me, I could have seen both series extended and would like to see them both redone in a serial 26 Episodes in length or better.

Are there other Mangas you know that were made into animes (OVA series now) where they were extremely shortened, but clearly could have been extended to highlight the more interesting elements of the series?

Was anyone else a fan of Masakazu Katsura?
Did anyone else enjoy either of the OVA shorts?

Offline ai-chan

  • Administrator
  • Shogun
  • *****
  • Posts: 2526
  • Karma: +13/-0
  • Collector
    • animeindia.com
Re: Video Girl Ai vs. I"s Pure
« Reply #1 on: January 01, 2012, 12:59:12 PM »
I haven't seen "I''s" yet, but "Video Girl Ai" is one of classic anime rom-coms for me. Sure, it does fall in ecchi, harem-like genre, but "Video Girl Ai" is a very sad and hopeful romance at heart.

Though not an OVA, I would recommend "Kimi ga Nozomu Eien".

Offline nickjeromana

  • Rurou
  • *
  • Posts: 33
  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Video Girl Ai vs. I"s Pure
« Reply #2 on: January 13, 2012, 11:57:58 AM »
Kimi ga Nozomu no Eien had 16 Episodes - Mitsuki's Route: First 14 30min/Last 2 45min+
Plus 2 Spin-Off series
"Next Season" - Following Haruka's Route
and
"Akane" - Following Akane's route

Though it's a great series, I don't see how it was dishonored by way of longevity.

The reason I wrote about both of these is because they only saw ONE release each.
First: Video Girl Ai (which took only the first Manga and First two chapters of the second)
----If you ever read the series, the story becomes QUITE deep in emotions, and very
addictive since Yota Moteuchi was never really completely dedicated to one person
or another.  Yes, he liked Moemi initially (as shown in the anime), however, he moved
on after he realized she was a lost cause.  Then again it gets quite messy with details
more than a Forum can tell.

The other was I"s which was very similar, however, they simply took all 15 Manga
and literally condensed them into a mere 6 episodes.  Having read the series,
I must say that again there was SO much going on in all 15 volumes that the anime
only could give the bare skin surface of the story.  Though better than Video Girl Ai
still left much uncovered.

I suppose if I had to name one similar case I'd have to point out "Oh! My Goddess!"
For those who remember the 5 Episode OVA, it ran rather fast paced and was over
before there was much time to really get used to the characters and so on.
-However, I'm sure for those who watched this OVA and then watched the
"Ah! My Goddess!" series, most would state that the Ah! My Goddess series was
significantly more memorable.  Why?  Simply put here you had 48 episodes to tell
the same story they tried to tell in 5 episodes.  I must say that Kei'ichi is much
more well balanced in the extended series as well. 
I still would like a season 3 out of that series.  Doubt it'll ever come though...

 

SMF 2.0.2 | SMF © 2011, Simple Machines
Cargo design by DzinerStudio

Page created in 0.264 seconds with 20 queries. (Pretty URLs adds 0.018s, 3q)